Charlie Gard

Single Payer, Single Decider…

One of my favorites to follow on Facebook is Hank Racette – you always know where he stands, and if he’s not sure of where he stands and is still sorting things out, he comes out with it.

One of his posts this week focused on health care and it is quite succinct.

Read on…

Single Payer, Single Decider

I’m sure you’ve all heard of the family in the UK that is now discovering the darkest side of single-payer health care, but I’ll briefly recap for those who have missed it.

Charlie Gard, a ten-month-old boy in the UK, is suffering from a genetic condition that has left him with brain damage and no hope of recovery in his British hospital.

A U.S. doctor is willing to try an experimental treatment, and his parents have raised more than a million dollars to cover the cost of moving their son to the U.S. and paying for the treatments.

However, even though this is the parents’ wish, and they’re ready and able to pay for it with their own money, the British and European Union experts have decided that the likelihood of treatment in the U.S. making a significant improvement in the child’s health is slim, and so have declared that the boy remains in the hospital, where his life support was scheduled to be switched off today (Friday, 30-Jun, 1700 BST).

Single payer, single decider.

That’s how it works.

In a pro-choice medical environment, where we respected the woman’s right to choose not to let her son die while medical options exist and she is able to pay for them, this wouldn’t happen.But when the government provides the health care, the government gets to decide when it’s worth trying to save a child, and when it’s time to let him die — even if the parents and their doctors want to keep fighting.

But when the government provides the health care, the government gets to decide when it’s worth trying to save a child, and when it’s time to let him die — even if the parents and their doctors want to keep fighting.

You don’t have to call it a “death panel,” this group that decided the parents can keep their million dollars because their kid is scheduled to die tomorrow.

Just call it socialized medicine.

A spokesperson for Great Ormond Street Hospital said earlier:

“As with all of our patients we are not able to, and nor will we, discuss these specific details of care.
“This is a very distressing situation for Charlie’s parents and all the staff involved and our focus remains with them.”

Charlie’s parents raised £1.3M on a crowdfunding site to pay for the experimental treatment in the US.

Ms. Yates (Charlie’s mother) previously indicated the money would go towards a charity for mitochondrial depletion syndrome if Charlie did “not get his chance”.

Whenever any country and/or organization loses focus on the dignity of life, then the foundation on which they have been founded ceases to exist – it is only a matter of time before that castle, that country, that organization comes crashing down for lack of a solid foundation.

And yet there are advocates that will say single payer is the path to go — one has to wonder just how long they would be believing this if Charlie Gard had been their own child.

No one gave anyone the right to play God — and they are playing God, even if their own ignorance says this is not so.

There will be a day, whether they believe in Him or not, their actions will be judged.

And truthfully, I don’t want to be anywhere near them when that happens.

sources:
Hank Racette – facebook
BBC News

 

return to top

Advertisements

Please Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s